Three ways to sell online, and the middle one is what we recommend most often. That makes this the one comparison on the site where both ends of the table sometimes beat the thing we usually sell.
Which one to choose
If the catalogue is small, there is one price and nobody signs in, buy the theme. It will be selling next month, the platform maintains it, and the money you did not spend is better used on product photography and a month of merchandising.
We would rather tell you that on the discovery call than build you something handsome that does not change the number.
If you are about to ask for a fully custom commerce build, we will probably talk you out of it. Payments, provincial tax, inventory and refunds are solved, boring and maintained by somebody else, and taking them on means owning a permanent maintenance obligation in exchange for flexibility you will use twice.
This one is against us in the other direction: it is the most expensive thing on the table and we are saying do not buy it. There are real exceptions, and they are commercial models no platform expresses, at a volume that pays for carrying it.
The middle column earns its cost in a specific place: the catalogue, the account pricing, or the product story is what does the selling, and the default storefront is the part that is generic.
That is most distributors, most manufacturers selling to trade, and most brands whose product needs explaining. Keep the engine, rebuild the thing in front of it, and spend the difference on the catalogue.